Supplements

12 Best Fish Oil Supplement Consumer Reports 2019 – Top Rated

The best fish oil supplements provide at least 1,000 mg EPA+DHA omega-3 fatty acids per serving, are certified by third-party labs and are sustainably sourced. To determine our top picks, we spoke with five doctors specializing in nutrition, consulted over a dozen scientific studies, and read hundreds of ingredients labels. Finally, we brought in our favorite three to experience ourselves.

Top 12 Fish Oil Supplement

$8.00Bestseller No. 1
Nature Made Fish Oil 1000 mg, 250 Softgels Value Size, Fish Oil Omega 3 Supplement For Heart Health
1,870 Reviews
Nature Made Fish Oil 1000 mg, 250 Softgels Value Size, Fish Oil Omega 3 Supplement For Heart Health
  • For a limited time, you may receive either bottle while we update our packaging. Both have the same great...
  • Contains a 125-day supply of Nature Made Fish Oil, 1000 mg softgels, 250 softgels per bottle.
$10.01Bestseller No. 2
Fish Oil by Nature's Bounty, Dietary Supplement, Omega-3, Supports Heart Health, 1200 mg Twin Packs, 360 Rapid Release Liquid Softgels
1,617 Reviews
Fish Oil by Nature's Bounty, Dietary Supplement, Omega-3, Supports Heart Health, 1200 mg Twin Packs, 360 Rapid Release Liquid Softgels
  • OMEGA 3S: Each serving of Nature's Bounty Fish Oil 1200 milligram soft gels contains 360 milligram of...
  • HEALTHY HEART AND METABOLISM: Omega 3 fatty acids, like those in Nature's Bounty Fish Oil, are considered...
$7.70Bestseller No. 3
Nordic Naturals Ultimate Omega, Lemon Flavor - 1280 mg Omega-3-120 Soft Gels - High-Potency Omega-3 Fish Oil Supplement with EPA & DHA - Promotes Brain & Heart Health - Non-GMO - 60 Servings
  • WHY OMEGA-3S - Research shows that the essential fatty acids EPA & DHA in fish oil support heart, brain,...
  • DOCTOR-RECOMMENDED FORMULA - Nordic Naturals Ultimate Omega features high concentration omega-3 fish oil...
Bestseller No. 4
New Chapter Wholemega Fish Oil Supplement - Wild Alaskan Salmon Oil with Omega-3 + Astaxanthin + Sustainably Caught - 120 Count (Packaging May Vary)
1,282 Reviews
New Chapter Wholemega Fish Oil Supplement - Wild Alaskan Salmon Oil with Omega-3 + Astaxanthin + Sustainably Caught - 120 Count (Packaging May Vary)
  • SUSTAINABLE FISH OIL: Wild-caught Salmon oil is 100% from Alaska, where sustainable fishing is state law....
  • 4 IN 1 BENEFITS: Heart, joint, eye, and brain support with 2000 mg of oil per serving that delivers vital...
$8.03Bestseller No. 5
Nature Made Fish Oil 1200mg, 230 Softgels Mega Size, Fish Oil Omega 3 Supplement For Heart Health
  • For a limited time, you may receive either bottle while we update our packaging. Both have the same great...
  • Contains a 115-day supply of Nature Made Fish Oil, 1200 mg softgels, 230 softgels per bottle.
Bestseller No. 6
Garden of Life Minami Supercritical Platinum Omega 3 Fish Oil Supplement - Orange, 60 Softgels, Ultimate Once Daily Fish Oil Omega 3 for Heart & Brain Health, 1100Mg Omega-3S, 1,000 Iu Vitamin D3
  • New Look, Same Formula; Previously named Minami MorEPA Platinum
  • For adults who want an ultra premium, convenient, once daily fish oil with the highest available Omega 3...
$3.60Bestseller No. 7
Triple Strength Omega-3 Fish Oil Supplement (Fish Oil Burpless), 3750mg Per Serving, 300 Softgels, EPA 2000mg & DHA 1500mg, Supports Cardiovascular Function & Immune System, Premium, Non-GMO
  • Triple Strength Burpless Fish Oil Omega 3 Supplement, 3750 mg per Serving, 300 Soft-gels, No GMOs.
  • It Contains High and Active EPA (Eicosapentaenoic Acid) and DHA (Docosahexaenoic Acid), Premium Fish Oil...
$6.90Bestseller No. 8
Nature Made Fish Oil Burp-Less 1000 mg, 150 Softgels, Fish Oil Omega 3 Supplement For Heart Health
  • For a limited time, you may receive either bottle while we update our packaging. Both have the same great...
  • Contains a 75-day supply of Nature Made Burp-Less Fish Oil, 1000 mg softgels, 150 softgels per bottle.
Bestseller No. 9
Omega 3 Fish Oil Supplement – Immune & Heart Support Benefits– Promotes Joint, Eyes, Brain & Skin Health - Non GMO, Pharmaceutical Grade - Lemon Flavor EPA 1200mg, DHA 900mg Fatty Acids Gluten Free
3,031 Reviews
Omega 3 Fish Oil Supplement – Immune & Heart Support Benefits– Promotes Joint, Eyes, Brain & Skin Health - Non GMO, Pharmaceutical Grade - Lemon Flavor EPA 1200mg, DHA 900mg Fatty Acids Gluten Free
  • Enhanced absorption and bioavailability: Unlike most fish oil supplements on the market, this ultra-pure...
  • Sustainably caught from iceland: The fish are never farm-raised; they are caught fresh from the pristine,...
$1.30Bestseller No. 10
Carlson - Super Omega-3 Gems, 1200 mg Omega-3 Fatty Acids with EPA and DHA, Wild-Caught Norwegian Fish Oil Supplement, Sustainably Sourced Fish Oil Capsules, Omega 3 Supplements, 100+30 Softgels
1,737 Reviews
Carlson - Super Omega-3 Gems, 1200 mg Omega-3 Fatty Acids with EPA and DHA, Wild-Caught Norwegian Fish Oil Supplement, Sustainably Sourced Fish Oil Capsules, Omega 3 Supplements, 100+30 Softgels
  • HEART, BRAIN, AND VISION HEALTH - Carlson Super Omega 3 fish oil pills provide the beneficial omega-3s...
  • 1,200 MG OF OMEGA-3 - A single serving of Carlson Super Omega-3 Gems contains 1200 mg of omega-3s.

How We Chose the Best Fish Oil Supplements

Third-party testing

We started with a mega-list of fish oils — nearly 200 in all. But because supplements don’t undergo the strident, top-down policing of prescription drugs, it was important to vet this list by way of independent testing. We required our picks to be approved by at least one third-party organization.

Omega-3s

Several kinds of omega-3 fatty acids are present in fish oil, including two of the three essential for humans: Eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). (The third — ALA, or alpha-linolenic acid — crops up in non-fish foods. We talk more about food sources of various omega-3s here.)

The World Health Organization and Consumer Lab both recommend 500 mg combined EPA and DHA for a minimum daily dose. We required all of our top picks to provide at least that in two or fewer soft gels. No one likes taking more pills (and paying for them) if they don’t have to.

No added colors or flavors

Color and flavor additives can disguise rancid fish oil in supplements that might otherwise look and smell like something you shouldn’t eat. What’s more, the easiest fish oil supplements to take — fruity chewables — typically contain a puny amount of nutrients. You might as well be administering Swedish Fish. We hate to say it, but fish oil should smell and taste like fish.

Five-star rating from the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC)

You can’t responsibly talk about consuming fish oil without talking about sustainability. Real, wild fish go into the fish oil supplements we consume, and they’re an important part of the ocean ecosystem. If any population is over-harvested, it causes a ripple effect all the way up and down the food chain.

In order to keep overfishing in check, the Marine Stewardship Council evaluates fisheries to make sure they use sustainable practices. To earn the MSC “blue label,” a fishery must take only a sustainable amount of fish out of the water, ensure its operations have a low environmental impact and comply with all relevant laws. Purchasing fish oil that aligns with MSC ethics means that what bolsters your health, bolsters the health of the product’s original ecology, too.

Guide to Fish Oil

As always, talk to your doctor

If you’ve ever looked into any nutritional supplement — be it biotin to make your hair grow or a B complex to quell anxiety — you know that the medical community is a perennially hung court. Studies are inconclusive. When it comes to fish oil, it has been proven effective against triglycerides but not much else, and some experts warn it can negatively interact with medications or exacerbate health problems. Talk to your MD to find out if some common concerns with taking fish oil (thinning blood, for example) should concern you.

Know if you’re already getting enough omega-3s

A supplement is designed to… well, supplement. If your diet is already rich in fish and omega-3-stocked nuts and grains, you probably don’t need to augment it with daily capsules. For the majority of North Americans, this won’t be the case. Western populations exhibit half the bodily supply of EPA+DHA than the population of Japan, where fish consumption is much higher.

Identify what is important to you in a fish oil supplement

People praise fish oil for soothing their joints and lowering their blood pressure, but it won’t have a chance to create any positive effects in you can’t afford it or can’t stomach it. Identify whether it’s price, flavor, or background practices that most impact your perspective, and shop accordingly.

Get the dosage right

As with any good thing, you can overdo fish oil, too. Even if you’re taking a top-of-the-line supplement that has been third-party tested for purity, like any of our top picks, an excessive dose can mess with your body. A standard daily dose of EPA+DHA: 1,000 mg. The FDA states that daily consumption should not exceed 3 grams (3,000 mg).

Like aspirin, fish oil is a blood-thinner, which makes it desirable for lowering blood pressure and reducing the risk of heart disease. “Too much fish oil increases bleeding time,” confirmed Dr. Rachel Carlton Abrams, author of Body Wise. “And that means for procedures, for injuries, if you fall and hit your head, you can bleed, like you’re taking aspirin.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *